“Competitive salary” tells a jobseeker remarkably little. Competitive with which employer, for which level of experience and at what number of pounds?

The Government’s proposal to require salary information in job adverts deserves a constructive Conservative response. Markets work through informed choices, and applicants should be able to judge whether a vacancy is worth pursuing before investing time in it. The legislation should preserve employers’ freedom to negotiate while making the advertised information useful.

A competitive labour market needs informed applicants as well as free employers.

Applicants’ time has a price

Recruitment is usually discussed as though the employer alone is making a choice. In reality, both sides are deciding whether to invest.

An employer may spend money advertising a vacancy, screening applications and interviewing candidates. The applicant spends time researching the company, preparing an application, travelling or rearranging work and family commitments to attend interviews.

Having spent much of my career in recruitment, I have seen how quickly a process can unravel when basic expectations were never aligned at the beginning. A candidate can reach the final stages only to discover that the employer’s idea of a competitive salary is several thousand pounds below their own.

Nobody has benefited. The employer has spent time assessing somebody it was unlikely to hire. The candidate has invested effort in an opportunity they might never have pursued had the pay been clear at the start.

Salary information will not remove every mismatch. Jobs differ in scope, candidates differ in experience and people value flexibility, location and progression differently. But better information can eliminate some avoidable ones.

That is a modest claim, and enough to justify the principle.

Openness belongs in a market argument

Pay transparency is often presented mainly as an employment-rights issue. There is also a straightforward market argument for it.

Prices convey information.

A worker deciding whether to move jobs is making an economic choice. They are comparing salary with commuting costs, working hours, flexibility, security, development opportunities and the risk of leaving an existing employer. Hiding one of the most important pieces of information makes that comparison harder.

Employers already expect applicants to provide substantial information before making an offer. Candidates disclose their qualifications, employment history, skills and often their reasons for wanting to move. Asking the employer to disclose the broad financial basis on which it hopes to recruit them is not an unreasonable exchange.

The Government announced on 5 November that it intends to make salary information in job adverts a legal requirement. The detail is not yet settled. Its earlier consultation on pay transparency in recruitment asked whether employers should publish a specific salary, a range or another benchmark, and what other financial information should be included.

That uncertainty matters. A sound principle can still produce poor regulation.

A salary range must mean something

The strongest objection is practical.

Employers do not always know the final salary before meeting candidates. A role advertised at one level may attract somebody capable of taking on greater responsibility. Internal pay relationships may also be commercially sensitive, particularly in smaller businesses where a new hire’s package affects expectations elsewhere.

Legislation should leave room for that reality.

Requiring every vacancy to carry a single fixed salary would be unnecessarily rigid. A genuine anticipated hiring range is more sensible, provided the range bears some relationship to what the employer is actually prepared to pay.

A range of £30,000 to £90,000 technically discloses salary while telling the applicant almost nothing. The purpose should be useful information rather than formal compliance.

Employers should also be able to explain where flexibility comes from. A vacancy might state a base range and make clear that the final offer depends on experience, location, professional accreditation or an expanded scope of responsibility. Where bonuses or commission form a significant part of expected earnings, candidates should be able to distinguish fixed from variable pay.

That still leaves room for negotiation.

The point of disclosure should not be to convert an advertised salary into a statutory final offer. It should give candidates a credible picture of the bargain the employer expects to make.

Make compliance simpler than concealment

The implementation details will determine whether this becomes useful information or another layer of employment administration.

The Government’s consultation explicitly said it wanted the new requirements to involve as little burden as possible and to avoid unnecessary reporting obligations. That should remain the test when the regulations are drafted.

For most employers, compliance ought to be straightforward: publish the anticipated salary or genuine range in the advert and explain any significant variable element.

Where an employer eventually makes a materially different offer because the job changed during recruitment or the candidate brought unexpected experience, it should be able to explain the difference. There is no obvious need for an elaborate approval process around an ordinary commercial judgement.

Enforcement should be proportionate too. An omitted or unclear salary should normally be capable of correction without turning every poorly drafted advert into a major compliance event.

The law will work better if publishing useful information is easier than finding ways around the requirement.

This is already becoming normal practice

The proposed law will not be introducing an entirely unfamiliar practice.

The CIPD’s Pay, performance and transparency research found that 41 per cent of organisations already always publish salary ranges in external job adverts. The Government says only 18 per cent always publish a specific salary, which is one reason the eventual legislation needs to distinguish between requiring useful information and insisting on a single fixed figure.

There are also signs that disclosure responds to labour-market conditions rather than moving in only one direction. Indeed’s UK Hiring Lab reported that the proportion of UK job postings carrying salary information had fallen from 64.9 per cent in February 2025 to 55.3 per cent that October as the jobs market weakened.

That is worth noticing. When applicants have less bargaining power, employers may feel less commercial pressure to disclose pay voluntarily. A minimum disclosure rule can therefore establish a consistent informational baseline without determining what employers must actually pay.

Better information will not fix the labour market

Salary transparency can easily be oversold.

It will not create vacancies. It will not determine the correct salary for a job. It will not prevent every employer from making a poor offer or every candidate from misjudging their market value.

Nor should publication itself be treated as proof that the policy has worked.

The useful questions come later. Are candidates discovering salary mismatches earlier? Are employers spending less time interviewing people whose expectations they cannot meet? Are jobseekers better able to compare opportunities before investing significant time in an application?

Those are more meaningful tests than simply counting how many adverts contain a pound sign.

The Government is therefore proposing a principle worth taking seriously, but the detail matters. Employers need room to negotiate and adapt jobs to strong candidates. Smaller businesses should not inherit complicated reporting machinery designed for large HR departments. Salary ranges need to communicate something real rather than becoming another compliance formula.

There is no inherent conflict between employer freedom and better information in the labour market.

Employers should remain free to decide what a job is worth and what they are willing to pay. Candidates should have enough information to decide whether the opportunity is worth their time.

“Competitive salary” is not information. It is an invitation to find out later.